American Idol: The Shocking Elimination Results!

bwhuffman:  773 days ago

This is ridiculous. However, it proves that you can't be complacent and not vote for your favorite contestant just because you think they're getting plenty of votes!

Mick:  773 days ago

She lacked personality on stage.

jim :  773 days ago

the just booted off the winning and the only one there who would be world famous . You lost a viewer

jim :  773 days ago

if she is gone then what in the world is jacob doing there ? he should have been gone two times back

Debbie:  773 days ago

Didn't see it coming and it was absolutely the wrong decision! Just goes to show how skewed the voting is - there is absolutely no way she should have gone home. I've lost faith in the entire process.

chuck:  773 days ago

She looked like a stepford wife singing. Haley is the winner even though she got picked on when pia was getting all the glory !
Go Haley !

Jolene:  773 days ago

The viewer voting should be cut in half as far as points go....the little girls just vote for the cutest male singer....not who has the most talent....Stefano and Paul should have gone weeks ago!

Sandy:  773 days ago

Everyone took it for granted that Pia was going to win and didn't bother to vote for her. Too bad. Our loss but she'll have a great career anyway.

http://www.ownapieceofamerica.com
http://www.ownapieceofamerica.us
http://www.veryclevergifts.com

fran:  773 days ago

i guess thats what happens when the teens vote, they dont understand what a good singer is , they just vote for the loudest...

Julie:  773 days ago

She didn't connect to the viewers, she acted like a diva. She was too confident for her own good. She should have shown some humility, or at least some personality.

Jen:  773 days ago

She was a good singer, but sooo BORING! That's why she's gone.

Marcus:  773 days ago

I guess the judges feel real stupid for wasting their ONE AND ONLY save on the red head dude with absolutely no chance of winning or having a real career in music. He's this year's Taylor Hicks! Randy, Steven, JLo = FAIL!

t jam :  773 days ago

SHE WAS GREAT AND WILL BE A HUGE STAR ,,BUT I THINK SHE KINDA WAS A BIT OVEER CONFIDENT THINK SHE WAS IT ,VERY BEAUTFUL AND WILL MAKE IT ANYWAYS GREAT NAME GREAT LOOK , DEFINETLY WRONG PERSON

Sue:  773 days ago

She sings well, but always the same--she was told several times to use the stage and she said she would, but never did.

Hurricane:  773 days ago

I agree,the judges used their save onthe wrong person,if Casey does win he will not be a star.